Home > Favourites, Making matches, online dating > OKCupid.com – For Jewish dating too

OKCupid.com – For Jewish dating too

September 28, 2010 Leave a comment Go to comments

I’ve never specifically endorsed any dating site in the past since for the most part they are all the same structure. Sign up, look at profiles, pay if you want to contact someone or if you want to read a message someone sent you (besides supertova which is free). And the build of the profiles is almost identical on all the conventional dating sites.

But I keep telling people about OKCupid because it is such a different online dating experience and so I feel it’s time for me to write about it here.

It’s free.

First of all, it’s free. Free free free. Did I mention that it’s free? Moving on…

You get matches that are appropriate for you.

No, it’s not a Jewish website (I did not mean to mention that right after the free thing!). But it is set up in a way that you can really have it geared towards who you are. In all the time I’ve been on (a few months), probably 99.9% of the guys who have contacted me have been Jews living in Israel. The site automatically sends you suggestions and there too mine are always Jewish men in Israel.

This is not the only reason I think that it doesn’t actually matter that it isn’t a Jewish site.

It’s *gasp* enjoyable to use.

Dating needs to be made as enjoyable as possible. This site is headed in that direction. There is actually something funky and fun about the site and when you visit it, you might actually feel a little funky and fun yourself. Even if it’s a dreaded dating site you’re visiting.

I honestly think it would be amazing if more religious people came on because the whole site seems to be more conducive to meeting interesting people than other sites. I know it’s possible that if you’re on the site long enough, there too you’ll feel like you’ve milked it for all its worth but it just seems to be different people than I’ve seen elsewhere online.

Higher quality

One of the main issues I have with jdate is that the majority of people on it in Israel don’t fill out their profiles. You’re lucky if there is a freakin’ photograph of this supposed potential match. And then these people who couldn’t even be bothered to tell you one thing about themselves contact you. Um, hello? It’s a big world out there. I need something to go on!

For some reason, most of the people on OKCupid have taken the time to fill out their profiles. It is possible that it is attracting totally different people than the other dating sites but my main theory regarding the amount of info up about the “average” (Jewish Israeli male) user is that the profile is way more fun to fill out.

Yup, it’s a pretty different style than what we’re used to. The questions are more creative and that seems to bring out a creative side in people. It asks you questions like: What are the six things you couldn’t live without? And: I’m really good at… And: What I’m doing with my life (instead of: I work in…). You’d be amazed how people answer questions that are worded differently.

Actually, reading people’s profiles can be an amusing past-time there! :)

The Google of online dating

OK, I’ve exuded enough enthusiasm but one more thing that is important to mention about OKCupid. It has been called the Google of online dating by the Boston Globe. This, I think, is because they are going all out figuring out algorithms for putting the “right” people together. They are taking the huge amount of information they are getting from the activity on the site and analysing it to understand what different kinds of people like, etc. They have a blog that is actually quite fascinating to read. Warning, it can be a little un-religious at times but if you’re up for it, I definitely recommend taking a look.

You can read about all the (very young!) people behind this enormous project on their about page. Wow they’re young!

Look, it’s new to me so maybe that is what makes it that much more exciting than the Jewish dating sites but I don’t think so. It is a very different experience for the better and tachles, I’ve met some interesting and nice people on the site, even if I have only gone out with a couple of them. I have found it to be a more quality experience than elsewhere.

And the minuses are:

I guess I’d say the minuses I have seen are that first of all of course you still must remember that people are people and not everyone is necessarily what they make themselves out to be. I went out with one guy from there who I was very excited about from his profile and then I felt like he was a totally different person in person. I was actually freaked out by that experience and shied away from OKCupid for a couple months after that. It almost felt like because the site is conducive to cool profiles it’s harder to tell when someone isn’t so cool.

Another negative would be that it is obviously missing some questions that might be important to religious Jews. The amazing thing is, though, that anyone can create quizzes on the site and someone could create one about religious issues which could totally become popular amongst religious people.

And one more negative (and this will probably be the biggest negative for some women especially): You do have some pretty random people looking at your profile. I’ve had a couple of Jordanians check me out, for example. None have contacted me but if there is already something uncomfortable about having your pictures and information up for strangers to see, it feels quite a bit more uncomfortable when it is totally “random” people taking a peek.

I recommend!

Either way, in general, it’s a cool site and I see that it already has a lot of non-Orthodox Israelis on it. I can totally see it becoming a nice change for the more traditional or religious Jewish crowds too. Now just for someone to start the trend…

If you check it out, let me know what you think!

P.S. FYI, they already offer a search of only Jews. Also, a user named Nevuchadnetzar has created a “How Jewish are you” test. I think there needs to be a more religious one created (though from a quick peek at his profile he seems to be religious himself) but point is, it’s possible.

  1. September 28, 2010 at 1:24 am | #1

    Okay, I’m trying this. Everyone on Frumster is a jerk, except for the yeshivish women. And one kinda-half-taking-it-slowly-BT I met.

    • September 28, 2010 at 1:27 am | #2

      Everyone’s a jerk? Wow! That’s a lot of people. Let me know what you think about okcupid. And I’m warning you: I don’t know how many Orthodox people there are there right now. START THE TREND, BOY! :)

  2. September 28, 2010 at 1:49 pm | #3

    I tried it and most of the ppl it suggested were non-Jews. And I was contacted by two Jordanians and a Chinese man (living in China). I suspended my acct… (shrug)

    • September 28, 2010 at 1:59 pm | #4

      rgoldstand, really? I’m so surprised. I wonder what the differences are between our profiles that you had such a different experience from me. Good to know!

  3. Ilana
    September 28, 2010 at 1:58 pm | #5

    Hi Deena,

    This is a really interesting blog post! I’ve been on OkCupid for over a year and it’s definitely one of the more fun ones (or possibly the only fun one). My friend told me about it last year – she joined because a friend told her that there were lots of Israelis on it and she met someone and they got married this past May!

    Two things I like about it: the question that asks about what you usually do on a Friday night – you can usually get some idea about whether Shabbat is at all important to the guy, and also the religion question and the fact that you can put “serious about it” or “laughing about it” etc. Although I do think that some people put random things for it as a bit of a joke…

    Having said that, I have only been on 2 or 3 dates with guys from the site and it never went past a first date. I still think it’s a fun site and I’m happy to stay on it and see what happens.

    • September 28, 2010 at 2:00 pm | #6

      llana, thanks for your thoughts. I’m glad you also enjoy the site. :)

  4. September 28, 2010 at 3:43 pm | #7

    I showed the blog post to OKCupid and I just got a reply from them. Among other things, they wrote:

    “Regarding Jewish-specific questions, we’re adding a feature in ~2ish months that allows us to publish match questions into the general pool that only certain users get. So for example, if you’re Jewish and serious about it you might get some specific q’s about that.”

    Nice!

    • September 28, 2010 at 3:49 pm | #8

      That’ll be good, because trying it out today, it keeps giving me women who are “not serious” or “laughing” about their Judaism.

  5. September 28, 2010 at 6:33 pm | #9

    My best friend has been on OKCupid for a few months now and she has met many men but none of them seem interested in having a meaningful relationship with her.

  6. insearchofhubby
    October 2, 2010 at 1:17 am | #10

    Deena,

    You totally sold the site to me!!! I am so signing up for it!!!

    • October 2, 2010 at 6:23 pm | #11

      Well then you must let me know how you like it!

  7. tamar
    November 28, 2010 at 12:17 pm | #12

    OkCupid is a great site. I’ve actually met a number of religious/traditional guys from the site in person – not because I met them on the site, because I met them in real life by coincidence- the type of people I could get along with would use the site.

    Unfortunately, it isn’t geared towards religious people at all, but you can customize your profile accordingly. I seem to be a bit too religious for most people on the site. I keep a profile because it’s free and its fun…:)

    • November 28, 2010 at 12:18 pm | #13

      See? If someone could say that a dating website is fun, it must be a good site! :) I really wish more religious people would start using it. It could be a great place for people to meet.

  8. Anonymous
    September 8, 2011 at 6:56 am | #14

    I’m real late to the commenting party, but I wanted to add my 22 cents on OKCupid, Jews using it, and competition with JDate.

    Caution: very long comment ahead.

    A) By late 2011, OKCupid seems to be achieving critical mass in the Jewish community. In the past two weeks, at Jewish events in my west coast city, I’ve had more than 10 people mention OKCupid to me (both guys and girls).

    Usually, when a lot of people in the community mention something, it’s going real big. JDate was the same way starting in about 2005.

    B) Overall, I see lots of people jumping ship from JDate to OKCupid and possibly PlentyOfFish. I started looking for info and found articles on OnlinePersonalsWatch that imply JDate is losing subscribers to OKCupid.

    JDate is being squeezed from both sides. Casual Jews can find other casual/cultural/ethnic Jews on free sites like OKCupid and JDate users who are truly concerned about only being exposed to Jewish –or observant– users are already on/moving to Frumster.

    JDate has been running a crazy number of sign-up specials this year… way more than they did in 2006-2009. It seems like every other chag/Valentine’s/Memorial Day/weekend has some 18%-50% off special.

    If they’re willing to give up the nest eggs like this, they must be hemorrhaging subscribers. I’m also noticing a significant (?) drop-off in the number of free profiles being created in NY, LA, SF, SD, and some smaller cities.

    Also, JDate has been ramping up their advertising and community event sponsorship big-time the past few months. They didn’t use to bother with it in the past.

    C) In response to everybody mentioning OKCupid, I signed on to OKCupid to look at profiles. After answering a lot of questions, and specifying that I only wanted to see Jewish matches (it’s under Advanced/Religion in Search), I saw profiles for a lot of ex-girlfriends and former friends and acquaintances.

    D) Re: RGoldstand not getting Jewish matches. In the multiple-choices questions section, there’s a question “Are you Jewish?” Make sure to answer it and to set it as a “Mandatory” response of “Yes” required by the other person.

    Then sort your search responses by “Match Percentage”.

    Also, ignore most of the “People You May Look” and “Similar Users” suggestions — most of them will not be Jewish.

    E) Re: RacyJC’s comments about people serious for relationships. Make sure to answer the many ‘Sexuality’ category questions. These include “Are you open to hooking up?”, “Do you want to get married in the next three years?”, etc. And make the other person’s desired response as Very Important/Mandatory.

    This will get rid of these people by “Match Percentage”. As long as you’re decent looking and have good photos, you should plenty of guys with the same relationship goals.

    F) Re: Tamar on finding observant Jews on OKCupid possible. True. Doing your questions/answers is very important. Make sure to customize the results you get. Also, do word searches for “shabbat/shabbos”, Jewish, etc. The word searches won’t find these words in the user box preset options, but will find those words typed into the user profile answers.

  9. fredricblum
    April 6, 2012 at 10:02 pm | #15

    I just deleted my OkCupid account because the only women interested in me were not Jewish, even though I stated that I’m somewhat serious about Judaism and my preference is to meet a Jewish woman, let alone that I’m a Kohen (which I didn’t say because almost nobody other than a traditional Jew knows what that means anyway.)

    Moreover, the Jewish women whose profiles I saw there were ” Jewish but not serious about it ” and were not interested in me either, because quite honestly anybody who is Jewish but not serious about it will date anybody anyway, Jewish or not.

    The site is no different in that sense than plentyofish.com

  10. Robby Robs
    July 13, 2012 at 12:06 am | #16

    I’ve been OKCupid in Israel for a year and from the many dates I have been on and emails I have been receiving I’m about 95% sure this is a site is for Israeli men looking to have a sexual relationship. There’s no doubt the men are more interesting and conversation worthy than the Israeli men on jdate but still feel disappointed by the quality of seriousiness.

    How is it so hard to find an Israeli in Tel Aviv who is smart, interesting, active AND serious??

  11. Robby Robs
    July 13, 2012 at 12:08 am | #17

    Oh I’m a non-religious single olah living in Tel Aviv

  1. October 2, 2010 at 6:39 pm | #1
  2. October 28, 2010 at 2:31 pm | #2
  3. January 3, 2011 at 11:27 pm | #3

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 38 other followers

%d bloggers like this: